Capital rationing is the strategy of picking up the most profitable projects to invest the available funds. Hard capital rationing and soft capital rationing are two different types of capital rationing practices applied during capital restrictions faced by a company in its capital budgeting process. In the efficient capital markets, a company’s aim is to maximize the shareholder’s wealth and its value by investing in all profitable projects. However, in real life, a company may realize that the internal and the external funds available for new investments may be limited.
Table of Contents
- 1 Definition of Hard and Soft Capital Rationing
- 2 Reasons for Hard Capital Rationing
- 3 Reasons for Soft Capital Rationing
- 4 Single Period and Multi-Period Capital Rationing
Definition of Hard and Soft Capital Rationing
There are two situations which may lead to capital rationing, namely hard and soft capital rationing. Hard capital rationing or “external” rationing occurs when the company faces problems in raising funds in the external equity markets. This can lead to the shortage of capital to finance the new projects in the company.
On the other hand, soft capital rationing or “internal” rationing is caused due to the internal policies of the company. The company may voluntarily have certain restrictions that limit the number of funds available for investments in projects. However, these restrictions can be modified in the future; hence, the term ‘soft’ is used for it.
Reasons for Hard Capital Rationing
Hard capital rationing is an external form of capital rationing. The company finds itself in a position where it is not able to generate external funds to finance its investments.
There could be several reasons for this scenario:
Generally, young start-up firms are not able to raise the funds from equity markets. This may happen despite the high projected returns or the lucrative future of the company.
Poor Management / Track Record
The external funds can also be affected by the bad track record of the company or the poor management team. The lenders can consider such companies as a risky asset and may shy away from investing in projects of these companies.
Quite often, medium-sized and large-sized companies rely on institutional investors and banks for most of their debt requirements. There may be restrictions and debt covenants placed by these lenders which affect the company’s fund-raising strategy.
Industry Specific Factors
There could be a general downfall in the entire industry affecting the fundraising abilities of a company.
Reasons for Soft Capital Rationing
Soft capital rationing, on the other hand, is a company-led capital restriction due to the following reasons:
The promoters of the company may decide to limit raising more capital too soon for the fear of losing control of the company’s operations. They may prefer to raise funds slowly and over a longer period to ensure their control of the company. Moreover, this could also help in getting a better valuation while raising capital in the future.
An increase in Opportunity Cost of Capital
Too much leverage in the capital structure makes the company a riskier investment. This leads to an increase in the opportunity cost of capital. The companies aim to keep their solvency and liquidity ratios under control by limiting the amount of debt raised.
The companies follow soft rationing to be ready for the opportunities available in the future, such as a project with a better rate of return or a decline in the cost of capital. There is prudence in conserving some capital for such future scenarios.
Single Period and Multi-Period Capital Rationing
Capital rationing can be distinguished on the basis of the period of rationing too. Single period rationing is when there is a capital shortage for one period only. Profitability Index (PI) is the most popular method used in this scenario. Multi-period rationing occurs when the shortage is for more than one period. Linear programming technique is used to rank projects in multi-period rationing.
Though the capital rationing seems to contradict maximizing shareholder wealth, it is a very important process of the budgeting process of a company. Depending on the type of capital rationing, the company can decide on the techniques for analyzing the investments.1–4